After Locke: A Tale of Two Scholar Cricketers

Ask Google or ChatGPT who the first Black Rhodes Scholar was, and you’re guaranteed to get the right answer – the life of Alain Locke, elected as a Rhodes Scholar in 1907, is extensively documented. But ask who was second, and the answers will be spectacularly wrong. Of course, search engines and AI chatbots are only as good as the source material they have to work with, so their failure is really just a reflection of the lack of published information about who followed Locke.

The correct answer, we believe, is that two people jointly hold the title of second Black Rhodes Scholar: George Hall (Queensland & Lincoln 1910) and Frederick Mercier (Jamaica & Jesus 1910), just 3 years after Locke came to Oxford.

Frederick Mercier

Born in 1888 in Jamaica, Mercier was educated at Wolmer’s School in Kingston and St Augustine’s College in Canterbury, UK before arriving in Oxford in 1910 to read Theology at Jesus College. We know little of his time at Oxford; he was a keen and talented cricketer, but found opportunities limited by racism within the game.

“A black cricketer called Frederick Mercier, a theology student from Jamaica who was studying at Jesus College, took part in a trial for the Oxford University team in 1911 and played for various teams, including Hampstead, between 1911 and 1912. Despite being heralded as unusually promising, he was never selected for Oxford, a fate shared by several other non-white cricketers at Oxford and Cambridge in the years before the Second World War.” 
-    Old Ebor, 2022

What we know of Mercier’s short life after Oxford is through the letters he occasionally exchanged with Francis Wylie, the Warden of Rhodes House. The most poignant of these was the first, dated 29 May 1915:

“I very much wish I could be doing something in the way of military work; but at present I am an Inspector of Schools in the Government & as I have a pretty wide area to cover my duties do not permit of my being attached to any of the Companies of the Jamaica Reserve Regiment that are being formed in various parishes in the Island”

“Several Jamaicans have already left for the Front - you would be astonished to see how interested even the humblest peasants out here are in the great European Conflict. The people are eager & ready to show their loyalty to the Throne & Empire. Already over £70,000 has been contributed to various funds & now it is hoped that a Jamaica Contingent consisting of not less than 500 men, & possibly 1000, will be sent off to England shortly.”

“We have received news of poor Stephenson’s death in France,”
- a reference to Daniel Stephenson (Jamaica & Lincoln 1911)

While Mercier initially seemed bound for the ministry, his career on returning to Jamaica was in education, first as an Inspector of Schools, and then Examiner for the Education Board. In later letters, Mercier regularly exhorted Wylie to visit Jamaica:

“Can we not induce you to pay us a visit some winter? I’m sure you would appreciate getting away from frost & cold & finding yourself in a land of bright sunshine”.

They discussed the progress of Jamaican Scholars who had followed Mercier:

“N. W. Manley has already made a name for himself at the Bar in Jamaica! We look forward to seeing him made a K.C. some day”.

Norman Manley (Jamaica & Jesus 1914) did indeed become a KC, and went on to become Chief Minister and subsequently Premier of Jamaica from 1955-62.

Mercier remained actively involved in cricket, serving as Secretary of the Melbourne Cricket Club in Kingston from 1923-4. When he died on 22 October 1924, aged just 36, after a short illness, his death was felt heavily by all who knew him.

A newspaper clipping reports “the funeral procession, the largest seen in Kingston for many a day, bore full testimony to the esteem in which our dear friend was held by the entire community”.

The cricket club noted, “it is with the deepest regret that the Committee record the death of one of its most esteemed members, Mr F. C. Mercier, M.A. The committee know that there is no member of the Association to whom the death of our dear friend has not proved a heavy blow.” 

William Mitchell of the Jamaica Schools Commission, and Secretary of the Rhodes Selection Committee for Jamaica, wrote, “the Department has lost an able, zealous and efficient officer and a very large circle mourn the loss of a true friend.”

Most moving of all was the report from Mercier’s mother, Catherine, in a 1925 letter to the Warden, of his final words. “Tell the boys I have played my last game of cricket, goodbye.”

George Hall

The Trust’s archives have much less on the life of George Hall, but more is known of his school career and post-Oxford life, thanks mainly to research by Michael Brumby for the Australian Dictionary of National Biography

Hall was born in 1891 at Charters Towers, Queensland to a white mother from England and black father from Tobago. Pamela Roberts, in her book Black Oxford, speculates that Hall’s mother, Annie Collett, travelled to Australia as part of a “bounty scheme” designed to encourage young couples and single women to start a new life in New South Wales. Roberts describes Hall’s father, George Hall, as a runaway slave who jumped ships to reach Australia.

Hall attended Townville Grammar School from 1905 to 1909 where he was cricket captain, senior gymnast, an outstanding footballer, shooter and swimmer, athletics champion three years in a row, head prefect and the school's best scholar. The esteem in which he is held by the school is demonstrated in the 1996 naming of the school’s new boarding house after Hall and fellow Rhodes Scholar, Chester Parker (Queensland & Christ Church 1938). A short biography of Hall featured in a 2016 school newsletter describes him as “a brilliant all-round student,” excelling both academically and on the sports field:

“On Sports’ Day he won the high jump, broad jump, 100, 440, 880 yards and mile as well as the 120 yards hurdles and throwing the cricket ball. His record for throwing the cricket ball was only broken in 1996.”

Both Brumby and Roberts quote headmaster Percy Rowland, “he has triumphed over prejudice by sheer merit; whatever will be his future, he can always look back on his years with us as years of success; whatever he does, he will carry with the hearty good wishes of all at the school.”

David Griffiths (New South Wales & Merton 1968), a Rhodes Scholar who has researched Hall’s life, believes that, if anything, most biographies understate Hall’s school achievements: “Hall’s breadth of achievement at high school can surely have only been matched by a handful of others in the first half of the 20th century, not only in Australia, but in the whole of the British Empire. I can think of no Australian, Rhodes Scholar or otherwise, who matched or bettered Hall’s school achievements during those 50 years. No wonder he was selected as Queensland’s 1910 Rhodes Scholar. And no wonder that it was possible for a public subscription to raise funds for his passage to England.”

Hall arrived in Oxford in 1910, initially to read medicine at Lincoln College, but later changing to engineering. Like Mercier, Hall continued to play cricket at Oxford, playing twice for Lincoln College and scoring 100 runs across two innings. Griffiths wonders, “if the prejudice against non-white cricketers led to both Hall and Mercier not ever playing for Oxford. He might have become a star all-rounder in the Varsity match had he ever got there.”

After leaving Oxford, Hall worked at as an inspector at a munitions factoring in Kilmarnock, Scotland before enlisting in the Royal Air Force in 1918. However, the war ended before he joined a flying squadron. 

The Trust lost touch with Hall after he left Oxford, and our archives contain little more than copies of letters trying to re-establish contact, and a flurry of correspondence regarding an incorrect report of his death in the early 1930s.

Hall returned to Australia in 1919, working with the New South Wales Cement, Lime and Coal Company in Kandos. He later moved to Sydney to join the Main Roads Board of NSW, rising (slowly) through the ranks to the position of supervising engineer. He continued to play cricket for many years – Griffiths describes a report by the Mudgee Guardian of Hall top-scoring with 101 runs in a 1923 match, and Brumby reports him being renowned as a “demon bowler” even at the age of 48.

Brumby concludes that despite his ability and recognition by his peers, racism limited Hall’s engineering career. He never married, telling workmates that his “ancestry would be a barrier”. After retirement, in 1956, he remained in Sydney and died in 1972, aged 80.

Antonia White, the Rhodes Trust’s archivist observes, “what fascinates me about Hall is that he must have been such a remarkable person to get a Rhodes Scholarship coming from his background in 1910. Maybe even more so than Alain Locke, who came from quite a distinguished and academic family. It is interesting that he seems to have excelled so much during his school years and won the support of everyone around him, and I think it is lovely that one of the buildings at his old school is named after him. It is sad that he never seemed to reach the heights in his career that he reached at school.”

With thanks to Antonia White and David Griffiths.

Share this article