Thinking about applying for the Rhodes Scholarship, or supporting someone who is? Sign up for our Rhodes Scholarship application advice mailing list.

Rhodes Scholarship logo on a bright blue background.

Ethics in the Age of AI: A Conversation with Michael Sandel

Monday 16 November, 2026

by Matthew Anzarouth (Québec & Keble 2025)

Much of the public debate about artificial intelligence has focused on doomsday scenarios: misinformation and deepfakes undermining democracy, mass job displacement deepening economic inequality, and AI agents escaping human control. 

Crucial though these dangers may be, Michael Sandel – a Harvard professor – believes that rapid advances in AI raise an even deeper anxiety: Will technology change what it means to be human?

This is the question that Sandel posed to the audience at the closing session of the Rhodes Forum on Technology and Society 2026. Sandel led a lively, interactive discussion – interspersed with clips of his interviews with figures like Conan O’Brien and Michael B. Jordan – about the ethical questions posed by AI technologies designed to replicate a range of functions that were once exclusively human. 

Michael Sandel

Michael Sandel

Sandel entered the scene of moral and political philosophy in the 1980s as a critic of Rawlsian liberalism. In particular, he challenged the view that democracies should be neutral toward competing conceptions of “the good life”, arguing instead that political deliberation should welcome citizens and leaders to articulate their views of human flourishing and defend their moral and spiritual convictions. He has put that model of public discourse into practice by leading Socratic discussions on controversial ethical issues such as genetic enhancement, the moral limits of markets, and affirmative action. These discussions, which have taken him from Harvard’s lecture halls to St Paul’s Cathedral in London to the Sydney Opera House in Australia, helped earn him his reputation as “the world’s most influential living philosopher”. 

The lecture at the Rhodes Forum was another example of Sandel’s preferred approach to moral and political deliberation, but this time with a fresh, urgent set of questions posed by dizzying advancements in AI. The conversation was organized around three domains: the performing arts, romance, and caregiving.

In the performing arts, the question up for debate was what Sandel called the “virtual comeback performance”. Suppose that AI made it possible to cast your favourite long-deceased actor in a modern film, using a hyperrealistic rendering of their image, movements, gestures, and likeness. Would this be objectionable? 

The conversation then turned to romance. Imagine a “marriage prediction app” that draws on vast amounts of personal data to produce a shortlist of three people in the entire world who would be the best lifelong partners for you. Would you prefer to draw on this list or one generated by your mom?

Finally, an already existing and widespread technology: AI companions. Would you support the use of AI companions, such as Intuition Robotics’ lamp-shaped ElliQ companion robot, to keep the elderly company in care homes? 

Sandel is known for making lectures feel more like conversations, and this talk was no exception. Audience members passionately shared their views on the ethical dilemmas posed by AI, and Sandel prodded them to articulate the moral principles underlying their intuitions. 

Two themes emerged in the discussion.

The first was an intriguing pattern of argument. Initially, participants were especially drawn to arguments about consent and freedom. As the conversation progressed, however, they began offering more nuanced arguments about the relationship between technology and our sense of humanity. 

As an example of the former, consider the audience’s reaction to the virtual comeback performance. Most audience members felt uneasy about the prospect of simulating their favourite dead actors in a modern hit. When asked to explain why, one participant argued that this would amount to a violation of the deceased actor’s right to consent. Michael B. Jordan, in an interview with Sandel, made the same point: “It’s not the man’s free will.”

It’s natural that we often grasp for arguments about agency when trying to express our unease with AI. These arguments are intuitive, easy to articulate, and deeply embedded in our liberal tradition that champions individual rights and freedoms.  

But Sandel believes that the crux of our moral discomfort with the virtual comeback performance runs deeper: “Suppose this objection [about consent] can be met. Imagine that permission was given through contracts and bequests… agreeing that, in the future, [dead actors’] images and likenesses can be reconfigured by AI to star in a new role?” Would there be anything objectionable about a consensual virtual comeback performance? 

Many audience members said yes, and Sandel asked them to express the moral argument underlying this intuition. Eventually, one participant – who attended and loved a 2026 ABBA hologram performance but confessed that she would pay more for the real thing – landed on that instinctive discomfort that many of us felt but had trouble putting into words. “I like authenticity,” she argued. “I don’t like trickery.”

But what exactly makes AI objectionably inauthentic? And are some AI technologies more guilty of this charge than others?

An unexpected paradox emerged. Despite their complaints that technology could never replicate “the real thing” – whether in film or companionship – many participants were particularly disturbed by hyperrealistic technologies. For example, while many audience members were comfortable with the use of a lamp-shaped AI companion robot in elderly care, a large majority were disturbed by Ubtech’s U1 robot, an ultrarealistic humanoid. The primary issue, then, is not so much that AI is incapable of replicating elements of the human experience; it’s that we don’t want it to. 

The second theme of the conversation centred on the moral costs of perfection. Objecting to the use of the marriage prediction app, Conan O’Brien – in an interview with Sandel – said he wanted to leave space for accident and fate. If we use technology to eliminate mistakes and imperfections, he argued, we will “remove the humanity from our human experience.” 

In Sandel’s words, perhaps “mistakes and imperfections and uncertainties are actually not experiences we want completely to overcome… Though we experience them as obstacles, they also point to something of human significance.”

For Sandel, identifying the fundamental moral stakes of AI technologies requires some gut searching. The problem with technologies that blur the line between the virtual and the actual, he suggested, has something to do with “human presence and authenticity.”

“That’s what we miss when we’re glued to our screens,” he concluded. “That’s what we experience when we gather together… arguing together, listening to one another, especially to those with whom we disagree. Social media makes this hard. Gatherings like this remind us that it’s possible and even sometimes exhilarating.”

There was something fitting, then, about the format of Sandel’s lecture. It made me think of the sociologist Émile Durkheim’s concept of “collective effervescence”: the experience of emotional connection and electricity that emerges when the attention of many individuals at a public gathering synchronizes on the same object. This description will be familiar to anyone who has attended a sporting event, a concert, a religious service, or a community celebration.

I couldn’t help but get the feeling that something similar was going on in the room during Sandel’s lecture. There were collective gasps when he played clips of hyperrealistic robots, affirming nods when an audience member articulated a familiar intuition, and even a palpable edge-of-seat excitement as attendees followed Sandel through a line of argument. It’s possible that the shared energy I’m describing arose because the audience was collectively fixated on a masterful lecturer. More fundamentally, I think it’s because we were enthralled by the experience of deliberation and gut searching – all in the hopes that, in a world that seems to be slipping out of our control, our intuitions about right and wrong might lead us to a better place. 

That kind of deliberative, face-to-face, distinctively human experience can be exhilarating indeed. Maybe we shouldn’t give it up.